84 Comments
User's avatar
Becky  Boltz Artz's avatar

Trump just needs to take them out completely! I know he cares about the innocent people, You just need to figure out a way to take them out and not hurt The innocent people… If he doesn’t take him out, they’re gonna take us out.

DefundProp98's avatar

Take out the physical capacity; not persons at large. Doable, stay the course. They cheated and broke their original agreements. Bad actors.

Irene's avatar

Iran regime needs to be completely changed. Iranian people are fed up with it the despotic terrorist regime with nothing democratic . Give them arms abd and let them act in a total revolution to overturn the regime and send the son of the shah ariamehr to rule on the democratic bases that country: on the other hand launch a blitz massive audit cause the elections are not at all as blue as they stolen them massively because in 2020 nobody went to.jail for stealing the elections. Reparations should be sent solely for the victims of J6 and not for facts happened 200 years ago . Is not our fault while the fault of jailing innocent people belongs to democrats for the acts they did in 2021 therefore they should support the consequences.

DefundProp98's avatar

So does the Blue Buffoon Wave need to be completely changed , but what did we do when we had a chance to wipe out our opposition?

Derek Hanley's avatar

I think you have provided an excellent analysis of the options Trump faced. In my view, the option for military action in Iran was the only option left after successive American presidents had failed to stop the Iranian march towards nuclear weapons with the intentions of "Death to America" and "Death to Israel". Bribery and attempts at negotiations had potentially delayed the Iranians from having nuclear weapons, but all evidence pointed to Iran's imminent ability to acquire them. The time and opportunity for new negotiations had gone. There were no peaceful options left.

I voted for Trump three times, but only because I thought he was the "least bad" option in each election.

Trump has an insufferable and pathetic ego. He talks too much and is now a laughingstock around the world, despite the positive actions he has made, as you described in your article

Having lived in Britain as a child through the second world war and the London Blitz, I studied how the allies won that war. America was the key element in winning the wars in Europe and Asia. Together, the allies were ruthless in fighting and winning those wars. The lesson I learned was that nations cannot win a war without overwhelming power and ruthlessness to destroy the enemy. In that case it was destroying the Nazis and their leadership, who were also ruthless. We bombed large cities to break the German public's support of Hitler. We used the atomic bomb to save Americal lives against the Japanese aggressors and the Japanese people who supported them.

Trump started a half-war with Iran. Not the kind that wins wars. He inexplicably stopped when he had the advantage and the dictatorship regime was still alive. He gave the Iranian dictators time to re-arm and consolidate their grip on the country. You can't claim to be a world-wide peacemaker and start a half-war. There is a British, maybe American expression: "You can't be serious".

However, to some degree, the jury is still out. I am not optimistic because you can never make a lasting peace deal with religious, fanatical zealots. It is not in their DNA.

DefundProp98's avatar

Trump acts, and that is what still counts. Not the words or personal style he has alway. used in public. What he does is highly productive. What he often blathers is only a side show.

Ann Churchill's avatar

Hard to believe there are so many fans of Islam out there, or was it just the price at the pump.Either way, a lot of people don't see what's actually going on,in the larger scale.

Jeff barton's avatar

I have always said about this war in Iran that I will tell you in ten years if it was a good idea. Unless you are Nostrafreakindamus you have no idea of how close Iran is to having a nuclear weapon. I further believe that it is the duty of America to herself and to her allies to prevent Iran from obtaining WMD. That said, the one thing the Trump administration could have done is to run an ad campaign reminding us of the horrors inflicted by Iran and her proxies against Americans and our allies. If our intelligence regarding Iran’s nuclear ambitions is true or even close to true I fully support this war including ground troops to finish the job and achieve regime change. I believe it is shortsighted to favor policy based on the price of a gallon of gas at the expense of the security of ourselves and our allies. Putting on my Nostradamus hat for a moment I predict that the unpopularity of this war combined with Democrat wins will soon result in Iran obtaining a nuclear weapon forever changing the balance of power in the world. At this point Trump will be recognized as the great visionary leader that he is, willing to make difficult decisions with disastrous political outcomes for the security of America and that is what America first truly means. But I am not Nostradamus so I will let you know in ten years.

Cate's avatar

IRAN’s IRGC: The US intervened to stop this 50 year global terror regime (IRGC) from a buildup of nuclear power.

Catherine Cuevas's avatar

Mr. Zepke, thanks for laying out the options. It's a useful way to frame the debate, and Vance's quote and his four reasons are accurately reported. But an article with this many specific claims needs sources, and several of these don't hold up:

– Inflation under Biden wasn't 57%. Consumer prices rose about 21% in total over his four years, and the annual rate peaked at 9.1% in June 2022. Inflation now isn't 5% either. September's 3.7% is the latest official annual figure, and none was published for October because of last year's shutdown.

– Israel didn't refuse to cooperate. The U.S. and Israel launched the war together on February 28. It was Spain, Italy and France that restricted U.S. access to their bases and airspace.

– The Vienna talks stalled in 2022, a year before the $6 billion prisoner swap in September 2023. That money was Iran's own frozen oil revenue, limited to humanitarian purchases, and it was frozen again after October 7.

– The 2020 Doha agreement called for withdrawing all U.S. forces from Afghanistan. It didn't include a plan to keep Bagram.

– The entire IRGC was designated a terrorist organization in 2019, not just the Quds Force.

– Iran has a sea border with Oman, not a land border.

– Who said "Iran will have a nuclear weapon in weeks"? Where does the 1,500 sanctions figure come from?

The argument deserves a hearing, and getting these facts right would make it stronger. Please add citations so readers can check them.

Harold Schaff's avatar

If you are going into a military action, go in and finish the job no matter what the criticism. Blow the country apart so there is no ability to respond. Don't try to walk a line of trying to be a humanitarian. They are not humanitarian and you need to deal with then as such. Yes you will be criticized by all the liberals but you wont lose your base.

John Doe's avatar

This was should never have come to be.

"Iran is weeks away-", ol Bibi's playbook - make up accusations of WMD or nuclear weapons to get the Hawks in america to take care of their enemies.

America should have pulled out of thr Middle East entirely, leaving the Middle east to fend for itself.

"But Iran will use nukes!" No they won't. Nukes are a deterrence, if Iran were to strike Israel they would destroy themselves in the process. The Iranian regime isn't stupid, they engage in low intensity attacks against U.S bases to make the cost of remaining in the M.E politically disastrous - not to incite a war.

It's not our homeland and we have zero ties to the M.E - tell Israel and the Gulf Monarchies to handle it on their own.

DefundProp98's avatar

The threat was a deadman switch - eminently doable with Iran's current supply of missles. Why is no one talking about the concurrent threat of a "drought" in Iran, that was requiring the entire population of Tehran be evacuated at the same time? What was that all about?

Was the municipal water supply being confiscated for Iran urgent nuclear enrichment? Lots was swirling around on the plate that is no longer part of the conversation. But need to be when so many partisan and hostile force now love playing Monday Morning quarterback.

Holly Ritter's avatar

Trumps only mistake was not prepping the American voter better. Better communications re: his decision to have military action against the mullahs. As for affordability? Blame Biden.

DefundProp98's avatar

The MSM screeches prevent "getting any message out". That is on the listener; not on Trump.

Election year coming up - Democrat mass hysteria covid brains are already at work again. AI mass hysteria is rapidly moving to replace their 2020 "covid" mass toilet paper hoarding hysteria. Same players, same game plan, just different objects of dread.

Anne Kalen's avatar

Special forces to take nuclear materials and continue sanctions and blockade

Arthur  C.'s avatar

Ok my problem is that President Trump did not have an exit plan with Iran, no country has ever surrendered by being bombed. You would need boots on the ground, which the US citizens was not going to go for. Now hit them hard and leave? Sure. But you didn’t, you failed to commit and were paying that price at the pumps and everything to do with diesel.

DefundProp98's avatar

Al Qaeda bombed America. Northern Ireland separatists was constantly bombing the UK. ..... this was not Hiroshima.

William Penn's avatar

Every President must live with the consequences when their decisions are not fully supported by the electorate. President Trump felt he had to break his promise of “no new wars” in order to deal with the real threat of Iran’s nuclear program. That then lead to higher fuel prices and higher inflation just when it appeared that Trump had slayed Biden’s inflation dragon. Trump then decided to slow walk the war with Iran, leaving the electorate with no end in sight. The electorate punished him for a “new” war that was hurting them in their daily lives with no end in sight. Remember what happened to Biden? Within months of taking office, he botched the Afghanistan withdrawal, humiliated the U.S. in the bargain, embolden Russia, then created an inflation nightmare with the Inflation Reduction Act and then opened the border to chaos but claimed that the border was “secure”. Whether one agrees with Biden’s policies or not, these policies contradicted his campaign persona of a competent politician with deep government experience and a moderate approach to governing. Whether it is Trump or Biden (or anyone else), you cannot run for office as one thing and wind up governing as another. The electorate does not take kindly to this type of dissonance.

Burton H Voorhees's avatar

Note that it was Biden who slayed the "inflation dragon." The inflation rate for 2024 was 2.9%.

Jeff barton's avatar

Another idiotic comment. Like congratulating yourself for putting out a fire you yourself set, inflation averaged 5% during the Biden administration much due to inflation reduction act spending on green bullshit. The integral over time sets prices not the number on a particular day.

DefundProp98's avatar

No, it was the 2024 GOP takeover of the House that slayed the inflation dragon and got it back to what it was during Trump #45. . The animal spirits responded after 2024, knowing continued Biden craziness would be checked by a GOP House, And it was.

Shawn Byrd's avatar

Should have used TOTAL WAR; BUT like Vietnam & Korea, Trump dabbled and tried B.S.ing. That leaves us with Option-3 PLUS in-depth sanctions, including CHINA. When will we ever learn that you never shoot to wound or punch back proportionately…punch with overwhelming force and destroy your enemy….this is NOT a condominium real estate deal.

DefundProp98's avatar

It was never a "war". Plus it allowed the USN to strategically move its ships closer to China, where they would be most likely needed should China make designs on Taiwan.

Think both logistically as well as strategically, like real C-I-C's are required to do 24/7. Sending USN across the huge Pacific in case of need in Taiwan vs across the Indian Ocean and round the corner from the Middle East? Plot this out on a globe and tell me what you think about this auxiliary benefit? Days crossing the Pacific being an exposed sitting dunk, with no land resupply bases?

Carmine indindoli's avatar

You are wasting your time, Americans want more sports broadcasts on nightly TV.

If Funky candidates promise that they will win

DefundProp98's avatar

We do need to rebuild national political expectations on exactly this state of affairs. Past decades of intentional teacher union K-12 indoctrination needs attention, if we are to expect any other outcomes than what you just stated. Ban all government schools. Support school choice.

Goal of public education was to create informed voters who carried out their duties in this unique Republic. I would consider that an entirely failed goal of our $800 billion dollars a years unionized public education industrial complex. Time is ripe to talk about this.

Time to rethink this massive annual tax dollar commitment to public K-12, in light of its now consistent and objective failures to even teach basic reading, writing and arithmetic. Stop wasting my tax dollars on any more Democrat teacher union-driven subversive drivel.

Jim Wickstrom's avatar

It’s amazing how dramatic the election turnaround was from only two years ago. And the author named several issues that affected the 2026 election, but on a national interview Trump said ICE was far too aggressive. No one has a problem deporting immigrants but there are thousands of stories nationally where Americans were assaulted by ICE and because ICE operates with impunity, and have no body cams or documentation so abuse still happens. Here is one our Hispanic friend, Sandra shared.

Her neighbor in Temecula was working in his front yard when an unmarked SUV pulled up and four masked men jump out and literally tackle him! His wife comes out of the house screaming “He was a US Marine! He was born in America!” She was ignored and her husband was cuffed and put in the SUV as his children were in hysterics!

His wife runs back in the house and brings out their passports and identification and finally uncuffed and with NO apology the agents got back in the SUV and left.

It was one more case of “mistaken identity” and of course there was no ICE documentation or body cam video footage. This is the United States of America. How can that be defended?

Jeff barton's avatar

What is apparently lost on you is that none of this would be necessary if Biden did not let in 10+M illegal aliens. Don’t blame ICE who has a near impossible task given the volume of illegals. The victim of mistaken identity should not be angry with ICE but should instead be angry with the Democrat party, repulsive worms that they are. Finally I have heard this story before and it sounds like bullshit or at least lavishly embellished.

Jim Wickstrom's avatar

Here is my question to you: immigrants come to America, and are easily hired by restaurants, hotels, farms, construction businesses. So, why are we not seeing any employers arrested and charged for illegal hiring of immigrants?

Jeff barton's avatar

What is apparently lost on you is that none of this would be necessary if Biden did not let in 10+M illegal aliens.

Jim Wickstrom's avatar

That sounds great if you’re a white American, but for you to suggest that the anecdotal story I shared with you about a Hispanic American is bullshit is your Achilles heel. We’ve all seen this happen on live TV!

It’s understandable you are angry now that Americans have chosen to elect 260 Democrats to the House of Representatives and 56 to the US Senate.

That is not the biggest issue, however. In Texas of all places, every single office from the governorship to school board elections went blue. That only means one thing: the entire 2028 presidential election will be decided in the state of Texas.

But I did get a laugh at your comment “repulsive worms that they are! Apparently you don’t understand what’s coming in 2027.

Jeff barton's avatar

What is apparently lost on you is that none of this would be necessary if Biden did not let in 10+M illegal aliens.

DefundProp98's avatar

America spoke. it is our job to live with what they chose. And hang them now out to dry too. No party can to anything if they don't get flooded with our own ttxdollrs to carry out their ruinous agenda.

Nothing wrong with a few additional Constitutional amendments to stop this free flow of our own cash into the rapacious hands of the government employee unions, for whom more power and more tax dollars is their only agenda.

DefundProp98's avatar

Anyone who bothers to read the stomach churning 24/7 relentless TDS hate attacks, lies and out and out intentional distortions, plus the role now played by millions of brain dead online "influencers" is only surprised Trump got as much done as he did.

Please read the 2024 RNC Platform - for promise mad and promises Trump did get put on the table - while running against this 24/7 and immediately Democrat obstruction and law fare campaign against him. Kudos to President Trump - God love you. You gave it your all and now are getting bashed relentlessly for doing what you promised voters you would be doing if they elected you.

Americans indeed are fickle lot. I think they voted for a time out from the incessant and vicious daily Trump bashing more than anything. Now we get to bash the Democrats. Bring it on. A far more worthy target since all they do is tax, spend and create a professional grievance class always demanding more. You own them now, America. Pay up.

Mike Baranowski's avatar

President George Herbert Walker Bush received approval from the US Congress and the United Nations for the Gulf War. He organized an alliance of 60 countries and 500,000 military troops to eject the Iraq armed forces from Kuwait. He did not invade Iraq as he did not have Congressional Approval for that mission. His mission was to remove the Iraq occupying army from Kuwait. Many Arab nations contributed armed forces to the conflict.

In contrast, President Trump unilaterally decides to go to war against Iran without Congressional approval or any allies. He expected a county of over 90 million people to capitulate after 90 days of air assaults. His execution of the war has been poor. He should have given a national address to the American people explaining the reasons for military action against a foreign country and then asking for Congressional approval as President Herbert Walker Bush did. During the deliberation period by the Congress, President Trump could have built pipelines and prepared for disruption of oil supplies.

President Trumps implementation of the tariffs was and is chaotic. One day is a 100% tariff on a country. The next day it's a 50% tariff on the same country. What was the tariff revenues used for? No disclosure from the Trump Administration. President Trump missed a historic opportunity of getting Congressional approval for all tariff revenues to be shared by the Social Security and Medicare programs. He would have been seen as the Savior of Social Security and Medicare.

Instead, working people experienced high gasoline and diesel prices and increasing prices at the grocery store and President Trump received 100% of the blame for higher prices. The Republican Party experienced the greatest Congressional defeats since 1974 which was just after President Nixon resigned from office after the Watergate hearings.

Michael Baranowski

DefundProp98's avatar

We did not gotto 'war against Iran." Bush I indeed did invade with ground troops against a real time incursion by Iraq into Kuwait. There are no comparisons to what is happening in Iran today. More like Obama and his Libya, Syria and Isis actions ....undeclared wars, that were hallmarks of his own 8 years in office.